Dad’s School vs. New School
Ever since we bought our first pack of Topps baseball cards it’s been pounded into our little brains how dominant Sandy Koufax had been. The most common reference point for this idea is the 1966 season during which “The Left Arm of God” pitched the Dodgers to the World Series while sporting a 27-9 mark with a 1.73 ERA and winning his 3rd CY Young Award in four seasons. Is this still the gold standard for pitcher performance?
Here are Sandy’s ’63-’66 averages:
24-7, 1.86 ERA
If the Dodgers received Übermensch pitching like this each day they would coast to 125 win seasons. Seems like everyone else was fighting for silver but we must at least glance at his contemporary’s peak stretches.
Bob Gibson: 20-10, 2.32 (’68-’71)
Juan Marichal: 23-9, 2.31 (also ’63-’66)
Advanced metrics for each pitcher’s totals from their four prime seasons provide us with more depth into their contributions. These two metrics are Wins Above Replacement level and K/BB ratio:
Koufax – 38 WAR (NL leader 2X), 4.7 K/BB
Gibson – 36 (NL leader 3X), 3.1
Marichal – 33 (NL leader in ’65), 4.7
Comparing their overall run prevention to that of freely available talent (WAR) and evaluating them based on outcomes they exhibit control over (strikeouts and walks) we find Koufax does in fact have a few worthy adversaries.
There have been only a handful of super-aces since this trio dominated opposing hitters at the outset of the expansion era. They are the usual suspects…
Big Unit (‘99-’02) – 33 WAR (NL leader all four years), 4.9 K/BB
Pedro (’97-’00) – 33 (NL leader once and AL leader 2X), 5.7
Mad Dog (’94-’97) – 34* (NL leader 3X), 6.7
*pro-rated to 35 starts in ’94 and 32 in ’95
Two things jump out immediately:
1) The cluster of extraordinary seasons occurring in vastly different run-scoring environments (4 runs/game in the ‘60s compared to nearly 5 in the late ‘90s) could be viewed as a confirmation of WAR as a wonderful “levels the playing field” metric.
2) 100% of the peak pitching stretches took form in the senior circuit and within two years of expansions.
That second point requires further study but we can safely say that while five hurlers have come extremely close, there isn’t one stretch of 4-year greatness that has equaled Koufax. Long live the gold standard!